User blog comment:J Fan/Favorite Duel(as of On Stranger Tides)/@comment-4693709-20120723001549

Duel in John Brown's blacksmith shop : I like the originality of the fight and the funny dialogues. I think it's at this moment that the persons that are seeing CotBP for the first time begin to really love the movie. Personally, it's from this moment that I begin to fall in love with the movie :P I like too Duel in the Captain's Daughter (that is a bit the same type of duel), but I prefer this one.

Duel on Isla Cruces : I like the fact that they're fighting to have the chest for themself, all for their own reasons. I like too the fact that they're really fighting into the set and taking advantage (or disavantage?) of this beautiful set (the beach, the church, the wheel, the forest, etc.). There's a certain suspens, and it's also pretty funny. At the end, the two fight end up together in a big fight, what end it perfectly. Finally, I like the music, wich takes back themes from CotBP and new ones. I agree with JFan saying that this is one of the greatest swordfights ever made in film history.

Duel on Isla de Muerta : Really love it 'cause it's the only fight between Jack an Barbossa (two of my favorites characters) and it's pretty entertaining. But I admit that the reason why I put it here is the music. In CotBP, we can heard the He's a Pirate theme a couple of times, mainly in this scene. But in the others movies, it never play in the full version. I really that we will have a fight scene in P5 with full He's a Pirates playing ! :D