User blog comment:Captain Josh Samsorrow/Plot Ideas for Pirates 5/@comment-5120604-20110528151023

Can we scrath the idea of Alantis right now? To me it doesn't sound pirate-y enough. Buried loot, haunted ships, that's a good plot. If you add to much myth to a pirate story, then it's not pirates at all*. Its a bunch of "wizards" on a ship. This is not meant to offend the pro-Alantis people, it just seems silly to me.

Also, this treasure Jack goes for, he must actully get it. Think about it. In CotBP, Jack goes after the Black Pearl. He finally gets it at the end. In DMC, Jack tries to get the Heart of Davy Jones. Although he puts up a good fight, he fails and is sent to the Locker. In AWE, Jack must overcome Beckett and Davy Jones in an epic battle. After winning, what does he get? Marooned on Tortuga. In OST, Jack tries for the fountain, but of course he doesn't get it (not that I'm complaining about that part, at least he got the Pearl, although its in a bottle). So in the next movie, Jack has to get something good out of the situation. This could be: -Jack getting the Pearl back together with his fleet -Jack finding some mysterious treasure (just brainstorming) -Jack having an "honest" relationship with Angelica

I think Barbossa and Angelica should be in it. The Spanish should be iin their too, just because they only had 10 mins. of screen time in OST.


 * Here are some pirate-y ventures: El Dorado, Treasure Island, The Black Flag (a pirate flag capable of summoning magical powers to whatever ship it flies on), The Stone of the Undead (brings a soul back to life i.e. Black Pearl's crew) and Black Bart's Ring (a ring that is able to control men to do there bidding)