User blog comment:The Flying Dutchman/Pirates 5 Idea - Pirates of the Caribbean: To the Land of the Lost Abyss/@comment-5120604-20110530180536

I would take the whole privateer part. Jack makes it said throughout the films he LOVES being a pirate. To see him as anything else would be irresponsible to the character. And where is Angelica?

And darker tones to a disney movie? No way. Another thing, enough with the doom and gloom in the situations. We had enough macabre in the third movie. A pirate movie in the end is not about banding together in face of struggle, its about freedom, which was shown nicely in the first and fourth movies. Sure there can be scary moments here and there but in the end we need it to be fun and exciting.

In the end though, I thought it seemed like it could be a good movie. Make it not so much like an all out battle royale and more of a treasure-hunt and then ye got a movie!