User blog comment:Mr. Joshamee Gibbs/P5 news/@comment-1984959-20120823220911/@comment-1984959-20120827184440

@A Wikia contributor, I understand how you feel(believe me, I've been there)...but facts are facts, and this is certainly not fact. The only truth behind this is that it is a rumor. Having seen many rumors throughout waiting for On Stranger Tides has made me..."cautious", I should say. And as MJG has said, The Sun has been well known for not being reliable...especially with this news not reaching, say, Comingsoon and Collider(who both do brilliant jobs at trying not to be unreliable).

''And now, in my humble opinion, he could do a much better job than Sam. Philip is a whelp in my opinion xD. But maybe if he returns, his character will grow in away, how knows.''
 * That's the point! As Philip is, in a way, the "new Will", he's suppose to be a whelp. As I said, I don't care if Philip comes back or not(as I wouldn't mind if he returned, but I won't freak out if he doesn't)...but William, on the other hand, should stay on the Dutchman where he belongs and away from P5. Both my opinion, and idea taking from evidence shown from AWE and of course how OST did in the theaters.