Thread:Uskok/@comment-34326446-20170826180630/@comment-996391-20170826183715

"I hate DMTNT, I think that we should NOT consider it as a POTC film because it has too many mistakes with the rest of the saga's plot. As we all know, some of these concern the compass, the Wicked Wench, Jack's hat, timeline and Jack Sparrow's bone trinket."


 * There we disagree. Most of these mistakes can be logically explained.

A) When the Trident was broken all the missing limbs and body parts of Salazar and his men were restored. Maybe that's how Will's heart found its way back into his body.

B) I admit that the curse of the Triangle is one of the weakest part of the film because it was never properly explained. But the way I see it, since the curse (this creepy red light) caused their deaths, it's not so impossible that once the curse was broken they were restored to their forms before they entered the Triangle.

C) Salazar and his men were trapped in the Triangle for many years. They had plenty of time to learn from their victims what they wanted. When the Triangle begins to sink you can see wrecks of several ships. It's possible Salazar interrogated their crews before he killed them.

D) The same answer as in C.

E) Finding historical accuracy in Pirates of the Caribbean is almost like seeing Nessie or a Yeti. Be grateful that there's any. As Ann C. Crispin, the author of Pirates of the Caribbean: The Price of Freedom, once said, "The important thing to understand is that this is not our world. It’s an alternate universe."

F) I have nothing against a little "secret history". The whole franchise is full of incorrect informations but that doesn't change anything about the real people, items or events that were featured in it.

G) Was Heinrich Schliemann a schizophrenic when he searched for Troy, a mythical place?

The films has its problems, but I wouldn't go so far to call it stupid.