User blog comment:HephaestusThePrivateer/Return of the Old Sword/@comment-4898132-20120226031351/@comment-4898132-20120226035229

And cause his old pistol might have been damaged or lost in the battle with the Revenge
 * According to On Stranger Tides: The Visual Guide, Barbossa "swapped his well-worn pirate's pistol" for the new pistol.

''Which old sword, by the way? Privateer or Pirate Sword?''
 * His pirate sword.