Thread:Uskok/@comment-37008292-20180925153218/@comment-30757877-20181006123714

I don't think that Jeff Nathanson checked this Wiki when writing the film. It could be possible, however, that Tia Dalma stole the compass and Jack retrieve it for Morgan and that sometime after receiving the Wicked Wench, Beckett bought it and Jack was forced to retake it. Then again, the screenwriters (except some like Jon Kasdan) usually don't care about a franchise's timeline and spin-off media, so The Price of Freedom wasn't taken into account during the film's development.