User blog comment:Pearl of Freedom/Will as Odysseus, Elisabeth as Penelope and Calypso as Calypso?/@comment-4898132-20110408235240/@comment-3534408-20110409004536

I wouldn`t go as far as to say that only true POTC fans want thi ending. It`s like Star Wars fans saying that everyone who didn`t like the Prequels or some of them or Greedo Shooting First isn`t a true fan. I consider myself a true fan and my beef with "broken curse" is that it opens a big can of worms. If Will`s heart wasn`t taken out, than we can talk about return to the living. But with that thing safely in the chest, it is just a Swiss cheese of new plot holes. So lets say the curse is broken. he is still heartless. Therefore, he isn`t human but immortal. But only CotFD can be immortal and once he isn`t CotFD (and T&T said calypso would choose another CotFD) his immortality would end, no? And ince his heart isn`t in him, and he isn`t immortal anyore, how is he going to live? I don`t mind suspension of disbelief but this asks way too much of fans who aren`t Willabethers and therefore not prone to buying any fan-pleasing cop-out. Besides, Will deserves better than Elsabeth so perfect ending would be "Frankly my dear, I don`t give a damn". : )