Thread:Uskok/@comment-27295021-20180325125431/@comment-4260948-20180409194124

Ninclow has a point about James Hook and Jim Hawkins. Word of Dod, for example, is the highest form of canon - it's how we know that Stranger and Dead Men take place in the 1750s and what we use to date the timeline with. So that means that, per Word of God, in the commentary, Jim Hawkin's father is the father of Jim Hawkins from Treasure Island.

And given that you still age with the Fountain of Youth, you just take someone's remaining years like Blackbeard planned to do to Angelica, that means that the only place "James" could have gone is, indeed, Neverland.