User blog comment:J Fan/Dead Men Tell No Tales - Details: Story, Characters and Setting/@comment-25426315-20150425143639/@comment-25426315-20150425192524

You got a sharp eye, but I'm not sure about Pintel. Lee Arenberg announced that he is not back, but even he was, I thought that this scene, with the Wicked Wench, is supposed to be a flashback. (Something rare for PotC movies, but we can't explain it somehow else. I mean, if it's not a flashback, then, could Jack have painted the Pearl all over again? No, and for what reason? Lol. So, it's definitely a flashback.)

And if he was Pintel, he couldn't have appeared on that scene, cause Jack met Barbossa and his crew in Tortuga, AFTER Beckett burned the ship, and Jones rised it, and Jack renamed it "Black Pearl". So, if this scene is taking place at the time that Jack was working for Beckett, Pintel could not appear. But he looks like him pretty much.