User blog comment:Captain Josh Samsorrow/Plot Ideas for Pirates 5/@comment-1932394-20110523051030

The story sounds great. But here are a few flaws: 1. The Aztec Gold Curse can't be done because like GIbbs said in the beggining of the Second Movie that "With the sea consuming Isla De Muerta....". Meaning that the island where the cursed gold is located is gone for the island sank to the bottom of the ocean. 2. The crew of flying dutchman aren't dead because they are already undead anyways and they serve under Will now. And the cursed crew of the black pearl can't be brought back for as said before, the cursed gold is gone forever. 3. As for the mermaids bringing black beard back to life, impossible because they will need to learn how to walk and we all saw how terrible Syrena was at walking with legs. Besides all that is left of Black Beard are just his bones. And the mermaids eat man because they are not only their food supply, but how cruel they are to the mermaids. so the mermaids wouldnt bring black beard back to life because of his cruelity. Also the mermaids do not know where the fountain is located because they never set foot on land, ever. And last but not least, davy jones is dead. though his spirit is a good idea, it can't happen because since he fell into th maelstrom when he died, he's pretty much, by my guess, is trapped in his own locker, where all of those who die at sea end up going to. This is means no diiferent for jones. Oh and before I forget, Quartermaster and Gunner are dead again, crushed by the giant pillar that was pulled off by the Spanish to destroy the Fountain. Idk what happened to Yeoman, but he's probably gone. But all in all, this is a good story, but the main enemies would have to be new, like they did with Black Beard in On Stranger Tides. But I do like the idea of Jack having some competition with his newly introduced brother, those would be all the funnies in the movie LOL.