Thread:Uskok/@comment-34326446-20170826180630/@comment-34326446-20170826213754

I understand other points except for A and G.

A) I know that. I think I have not explained well. I will make a example: we have three consequent points:

1 Will/Salazar is live

2-Will/Salazar dies

3-Will/Salazar become cursed

If we delete point 3 we go back to point 2 not to the point 1. Will's curse as like as Salazar's was the only way to safe them from the death. If this curse are broken, the only way to safe them from the dead is broken, so they should have to come back as they were just before being cursed, dead.

G) About Schliemann I can tell you that you can not make a comparison between Troy and Poseidon's Trident.Troy was just a city built by normal humans. The Trojan War narrates in the Iliad has a real historical foundation. Most historians think that the famous war was the concequence of a mycenaean invasion in the area of Troy in order to obtein the rule of thecommercial route on the Black Sea. The popular tradition has made the poems that we know. But the Trident of Poseidon is different think. It's just a symbol, a weapon of a god, gods couldn't exist. The trident is just a idiomatoc symbol created by the greeck iconography, the traditional divine attribute featured in many ancient depictions. The trident is a symbolic object, Troy was a specific place in a specific location in a real world.

Of course DMTNT is more and more stupid than the other four films.

And I also have another question: Did Disney give some explanations about the mistakes about the compass and about the Wicked Wench's origins? Because these are very serious mistakes. It almost seems that Disney ignored the events of The Price of Freedom. This is a very serious problem. And I think that say that Jack obtained the Wench by Morgan and then he reobtained it by Beckett it's too easy and not credible. It would be more correct to say the truth, that Disney has (unfortuntely) given two different versions of the story. The same for the compass, the hat and the trinket.

Thank you.