User blog comment:WillTurner101/On Stranger Tides Question/@comment-1984959-20120407075635/@comment-1984959-20120412141434

Yes, we know that. But I mean what happened AFTER the fight in the Captain's Daughter. Even in DMC, where it was eaten by the Kraken, Jack was reunited with it. Many fans of Captain Jack wants Jack to be reunited with his hat in some way or another.