User blog comment:CutlerBeckett/Will Turner or Philip Swift/@comment-4693709-20120825233006

My question is : why would one of them would have to come back ?

For Will, we know it's finish. I understand that his fans are sad of that, but it's absolutely sure he won't come back, in less of a cameo or in a short film, as J Fan said. His story ended in AWE, and I'm personally more than fine with that.

For Philip... then this is more my personnal opinion on the matter. I really didn't like him. You can see my complete review on him and Syrena here. But, when I think at it... there is chances that he will come back. It's not sure, but there's chances.