Thread:Uskok/@comment-34326446-20170826180630

Firstable sorry for my english.

I'm an admin of Pirati dei Caraibi wiki (the Italian POTC wiki). And I have some questions about DMTNT...

I hate DMTNT, I think that we should NOT consider it as a POTC film because it has too many mistakes with the rest of the saga's plot. As we all know, some of these concern the compass, the Wicked Wench, Jack's hat, timeline and Jack Sparrow's bone trinket. But there are other plot holes in this horrible film:

A) With the destruction of the Trident of Poseidon and the consequent end of all the se curse, Will Turner shouldn't be dead? Stabbing Davy Jone's heart and becoming the Dutchman's captain was the only way to save Will from the death...if the curse is broken Will should have become dead again. Isn't it?

B) The same thing for Salazar. In Salazar's flashback we see that he and his crew were cursed AFTER their death. With the destruction of the curse, they should have come back to the death.

C) How does Salazar know about the existence of the compass and also about his powers?

D) How does Salzar know the identity of Jack Sparrow. He just saw Jack at a grat distance.

E) It was too difficult for writers go on wikipedia and see that Saint Martin has never been ruled by the British.

F) It was absolutely NOT necessary to dissipate the reputation of old Galileo. It was enough to invent another name...This is disinformation.

G) Carina is schizophrenic. She says "I'm a woman of science. I choose not to belive in ghosts." But she is searching for the Trident of Poseidon, a mythical weapon. Is she ok??

This film is illogical and stupid.

Thank yoy for your attention. :-) 