User blog comment:The Flying Dutchman/Pirates 5 Idea - Pirates of the Caribbean: To the Land of the Lost Abyss/@comment-63.216.106.106-20110705115830

the thing is that in all of the story jack is either seduced or forced into doing something by losing his freedom. jack is too conning to lose he's freedom for 2 years and he would never be seduced as easily as he did in this story .in the 4 movies we always see jack getting the upper hand on a deal even if it dosen't seem like it but he always gets the better end of a deal if anything he would have become a privateer and 2 days later he would have turned back into a pirate .this jack in this story seemes alot weaker then the jack we all know and love.and why would barbossa ever give up he's ship for anyone or anything but other then that i liked it alot it has some nice twists and it's not that related to the 4th movie ,i think it has creativity .love the name by the way