User blog comment:J Fan/Favorite Duel(as of On Stranger Tides)/@comment-4693709-20120723001549/@comment-1984959-20120723010738

Duel in John Brown's blacksmith shop : I like too Duel in the Captain's Daughter (that is a bit the same type of duel), but I prefer this one.
 * While the blacksmith shop duel isn't one of my list of favorite duels(well, except in terms of fav "BIG sword duels"), I did like it. But comparing it to the Captain's Daughter duel, well...I like the latter better(I guess I'm a sucker for seeing Jack with his entire pirate gear lol).

Duel on Isla Cruces : I like too the fact that they're really fighting into the set and taking advantage (or disavantage?) of this beautiful set (the beach, the church, the wheel, the forest, etc.). There's a certain suspens, and it's also pretty funny.
 * Funny you should mention that, as there was a deleted scene that showed more of the fight on the beach titled Three Swords - One Key(it wasn't released online, I only knew about it from the "Four-movie collection" and was able to find caps from DMC featurettes). It was a great scene with even more choreography...even though it kinda differs from what's seen in the final cut.

Duel on Isla de Muerta : Really love it 'cause it's the only fight between Jack an Barbossa (two of my favorites characters) and it's pretty entertaining.
 * Don't forget the very brief fight aboard the Santiago]. Ha! Only kidding...but I got your point. lol ;)

''But I admit that the reason why I put it here is the music. '''In CotBP, we can heard the He's a Pirate theme a couple of times, mainly in this scene. But in the others movies, it never play in the full version.''' I really that we will have a fight scene in P5 with full He's a Pirates playing ! :D''
 * Actually, in terms of the first 20-ish seconds of the tune, He's a Pirate was never played at any other moment than the Jack/Barbossa duel. But yea, that's why I consider that duel one of the most iconic scenes in POTC. I'd like to hear it at some point other than the ending credits...but then, I think it would ruin the magic of CotBP(just my opinion on the matter).