User blog comment:CutlerBeckett/Will Turner or Philip Swift/@comment-5439673-20120826100759/@comment-1984959-20120826123438

''I just have to add that I don't believe that any of them is coming back. Will's story in deed is ended as is Philip's. Mermaid's kiss protects a man of drowning.''
 * As much as I like to disagree(as I personally would like to see Philip again)...I must agree to that. If Philip wasn't to return in P5, I wouldn't be mad because of, as you said, the mermaid's kiss. But then, there's my curiosity of where these two would've gone...more than I can say for Will and Elizabeth's story, I'm afraid. So if not P5, some other material explaining should do justice.