Thread:J Fan/@comment-5221892-20121029134515/@comment-1984959-20121029141801

Sorry, but we try and take our article's names from any available official material. And the names given to that particular medallion, taken from POTC "Master Replicas" products, are either "Elizabeth Swann's Necklace Replica"(the product's name) or "Elizabeth Swann's gold medallion"(named in the product description). Besides, that's what the "Dispute" template is for - to let visitors know that the name may not be fact(for reasons you already stated).

The only other name officially given to the item in question was "Aztec Medallion", or something along the lines. But because that might end up being contradictory, it'd be best to leave it as Elizabeth's medallion, as she had the medallion for quite a long time compared to Will and Bootstrap Bill. If you think about it, the medallion never belonged to anyone...it was stolen from the stone chest at Isla de Muerta. ;)