User blog comment:Orocostasol/Will Turner's return finally confirmed/@comment-1984959-20150531183406/@comment-31601543-20150601191113

Yeah, what you are saying is a pretty valid criticism. It doesn't make sense in a Doyalist standpont because it messes up the ending of AWE. It doesn't make sense at a Watsonian standpoint because Will is busy ferrying souls and having only one day at land. (Watsonian means in universe while Doyalist means out of universe.) But hey, if it works, it works. If it doesn't, it doesn't. That's the way things are.