User blog comment:ARC Trooper Tal/Queen Anne's Revenge Vs. Flying Dutchman/@comment-216.116.3.102-20171007053831

Well, Let's look at firepower. The revenge has less cannons than the flying dutchman around 36-38 not counting the fire cannons, and they are all 12 pound cannons. However, so did the black pearl. Yet the pearl under barbossa's reign destroyed many ships and earned a spot in potc universe folklore of supernatrual ghost ships. One can imagine the pearl sneaking up to reack havock. Much like the dutchman's opening scene in potc3. And the pearl put up a good fight against the dutchman. So, I'd say it's a tie. Now as for supernatural power, davy jones is an immortal god of the sea and captain of a freaking ghost ship. Blackbeard is a voodoo person who uses voodoo and extra cannons to make something out of some spanish slave ship he found. I'd say jones would win this fight. However, the queen anne's revenge would probably put some massive holes in the dutchman first.