User blog comment:Mr. Joshamee Gibbs/P5 : Philip Swift's return?/@comment-1140008-20120621004536/@comment-184.160.4.105-20120623005746

Syrena could fit in any scene that is filmed on water, or underwater(PLEASE ATLANTIS !!!), and I don't know why, but I'm completely sure that there will be a lot of scene on water in Pirates 5 (like all the others movies). So J Fan was right, I was talking about Philip to be without Syrena in POTC 5 when I said it could be pretty hard, or even impossible.

But I understand your two opinions, and I agree that Astrid Bergeys-Frisbey had the physical appearance that her character needed. Maybe that the producers thought that everyone needs a first chance, since it was her first film not in french. And it's true. But maybe that she should have begun with something a little bit less big that OST.

But, anyway, what is done is done, let's see what the future will reserve for us ! :D

PS :

Though I think what MJB was talking about was that it would be hard to work out putting Philip alone in P5(as he's now tied to Syrena in terms of the POTC fanbase).

Just to know, J Fan, when you said "MJB", were you talking about me ? 'Cause I don't see any "B" in Gibbs... hahaha, just kidding ;).