User blog comment:DonDorado/OST Jacks sword/@comment-1984959-20120328184810

Scrum and Philip never held Jack's sword; they weilded cutlasses. Though I can understand why they could easily be mistaken as Jack's sword(as the sword looks like a longer version of a cutlass).

Angelica, however, is likely to have held Jack's sword at least one in the film, as she seemed to have taken off his hat, coat, and his other effects when Jack was shanghaied aboard the QAR. In the original script, Angelica tossed Jack's sword back to him after the mermaid attack at Whitecap Bay(evidenced by a promotional image in the Disney Second Screen feature, as well as this screenshot from a featurette).