Thread:141.0.9.55/@comment-1984959-20120709044249

To reply to your message:
 * However, is it well and truly necessary to have a five line page on the city of Glasgow, which is only significant due to it being the birthplace of three characters.

To answer this statement or question: yes! Even if something is a brief mention in POTC media, it must have its own page or at least a section in our Wiki's Codex.

''It is never mentioned in canon, nor is it ever depicted in any film, book or other canon resource. This page is, point proven, unnecessary. If I had an account, I would recommend it for deletion.''
 * Our wiki doesn't take its entire content strictly from movies; if that were the case, we wouldn't have "Sword of Triton" and many other stuff we have in our articles.

''It is never mentioned in canon, nor is it ever depicted in any film, book or other canon resource. This page is, point proven, unnecessary. If I had an account, I would recommend it for deletion.''
 * This is where I would like to correct you in saying that Glasgow was in fact mentioned in canon resources. As followed(including sources that are within the article itself):


 * The Curse of the Black Pearl first screenplay draft - Not saying everything from scripts is canon, but as Glasgow was mentioned in other POTC-related sources, we have to take it as fact.
 * Dead Man's Chest "Heroes and Villains" action figures - Ok, same as the screenplay draft, this may be somewhat ridiculous of a source. Again, we wouldn't be keeping it as fact unless if we have a bigger source, which will be mentioned in my next point...
 * The official POTC website - Unfortunately, the information is currently no longer there(as changes were made in late 2010-early 2011 for the release of OST). But me and some others here do remember reading some info from the site...one of which, of course, Bootstrap Bill and Will Turner were born in Glasgow.

Now that I provided my sources, which are reliable as per our Wiki's guidelines, the matter should be concluded in saying that Glasgow does not need be deleted. Hope this helps clarify things!

And for future reference, please discuss matters such as these in talk pages...which can be accessed by pressing the "Talk" button - located right beside the black button titled "Edit". Either that or message any of our many users, admins included. Savvy? 