Shipwreck art "We are an unimaginative lot when it comes to naming things."

The title of this article is conjectural.
Although this article is based on canonical information, the actual name of this subject is pure conjecture. Please see the reasons for this title in the "Behind the scenes" section below, and/or the relevant discussion on the talk page.


Escape from Cannibal Island


Battle of Isla Cruces

Destruction of the Edinburgh Trader

Search for the Dead Man's Chest




Caribbean Sea


Destruction of the Edinburgh Trader. Full imprisonment of Bootstrap Bill Turner. Will Turner escapes from Davy Jones' wrath (temporarily).

Crew of the Flying Dutchman

Edinburgh Trader flag

Crew of the Edinburgh Trader

Davy Jones

Captain Bellamy


Dozens of crewmen

Dozens of crewmen
William Turner


Slight injuries to the Kraken

The Edinburgh Trader destroyed
The entire crew killed (except for William Turner)

"Let no joyful voice be heard. Let no man look up at the sky with hope. And let this day be cursed by we who ready to wake...the Kraken!"
Davy Jones upon releasing the Kraken.[src]

The Destruction of the Edinburgh Trader was a battle between the Edinburgh Trader and the Kraken, that resulted in Will Turner's escape, and the destruction of the ship. This was also the first battle in the search for the Dead Man's Chest.


Escape with a KeyEdit

"Master Turner, feel free to go ashore…the very next time we make port!"
―Davy Jones to William Turner[src]
Dutchman in telescope

The Flying Dutchman following the Edinburgh Trader.

Will Turner, who had leeway to leave the Flying Dutchman, silently escaped the ship one night after his capture with the Key to the Dead Man's Chest in his possession. When Davy Jones found out it was missing, he quickly realized that Jack Sparrow was attempting to recover the Dead Man's Chest despite his offer for more crew members, and gave chase to Turner.

Summon the Kraken

Davy Jones summoning the Kraken.

The crew of the Edinburgh Trader caught Will at sea and brought him on board. As the Dutchman came up on the Trader, Jones had Bootstrap Bill Turner (Will's father) taken up on deck, so as to punish him for aiding in Will's escape. However, instead of giving Will the mercy of killing him in Ship to Ship combat, Jones used the Kraken Hammer, summoning the Kraken to destroy the Trader, in spite of Bootstrap's horror.

The BattleEdit

The Trader's haltEdit

"We must of hit a reef!"
Quartermaster (Edinburgh Trader)[src]

When the Flying Dutchman was spotted by the crew of the Edinburgh Trader, Captain Bellamy used his spyglass to confirm which ship was approaching. Will Turner climbed up to the mast of the ship and deduced that the Dutchman was getting closer and closer to them, inferring that he had condemned not only himself, but also his rescuers. Desperate to warn his allies, Turner yelled at Bellamy that the ship he was staring intently at was the Dutchman, but in that moment, the Trader came to a halt after apparently hitting a reef, as the ship's Quartermaster guessed. By the impact, Turner almost fell to his death on the Trader's deck, however he managed to avoid such a fate by holding onto the sail's ropes.


Captain Bellamy checking what had hit the Edinburgh Trader before giving his final order.

Bellamy along the Cook and the Bursar of the Trader moved to the railing to find the supposed reef with which they had impacted, however they only saw pure sea water. Without understanding what had happened, Bellamy gave the order to his helmsman to turn the rudder to set sail to another direction, an order that was repeated by the Deckhand and the Cook.

The Kraken StrikesEdit

Kraken attacks 2

The Kraken start its attack.

At that moment, the Trader suddenly came to a halt because the Kraken hooked on to the ship, unknown to its crew. As Captain Bellamy gave orders to the crew, he was suddenly grabbed by a giant tentacle and was pulled into the sea. A Sailor noticed Bellamy's undoing, but was to scared to say something to the Cook and the Bursar before the two came to understand what he was attempting to communicate to them. They found out when Bellamy emerged from the water one last time. The captain was last seen screaming as the tentacle whipped him around before sucking him back under the water again to his death, which alerted the whole crew of the Kraken's presence. As the Kraken's tentacles slowly moved up the hull of the ship, the crew members of the Edinburgh Trader frantically armed themselves with cutlasses, pistols, axes, muskets and spears to attempted to defend themselves from the Kraken. William Turner who was already on the rigging into the main mast, was able to take in the scene from above.

Kraken attacks 11

The Kraken eats the crew.

The Kraken's tentacles were too strong for any of these smaller armaments, and many crewmen were grabbed. The Bursar of the ship, believing the Kraken attack was because of the widowed spirit, desperately attempted to make an offering of Elizabeth's dress but was soon snatched by a tentacle himself. The Kraken then snapped the main mast, forcing Will to spring onto the next one as it fell. Then, in one final move, the Kraken brought down two enormous tentacles onto the ship causing it to break in half. This allowed the Kraken to surface at the center of the destruction and easily drag crew members into its open mouth. Will dove into the water away from the Kraken as the pillar of the final mast that he was holding onto was crushed.


"The chest is no longer safe. Chart a course to Isla Cruces. Get me there first, or there'll be the devil to pay!"
"Who sent that thieving charlatan on to my ship, who told him of the key?...Jack Sparrow."
Davy Jones and Koleniko[src]
Kraken attacks 14

Will escapes the attack.

While neither Davy Jones or the crew of the Flying Dutchman suffered any casualties, the Kraken suffered some, as it was left with slight injuries inflicted by the weapons of the Edinburgh Trader's crew, albeit its injuries were not from major damage.

Every crewmember of the Edinburgh Trader was killed, except Will Turner. The rest of the survivors, including the Cook and the Sailor, were killed by the crew of the Flying Dutchman under Davy Jones' orders. In the aftermath of this, Jones ordered Bill Turner to be sent to the brig, where he would spend the next couple months, slowly merging with the ship. Will, though silently stowed on board the Dutchman. When the Dutchman sailed to Isla Cruces, Will went with them, intent on finding the Dead Man's Chest and Jack Sparrow.


Notes and referencesEdit

  1. James "Jim" Carson's calendar of Henry Turner's waiting for Will Turner's return from Dead Men Tell No Tales shows that Will's first visit to his family after ten years of captaining the Flying Dutchman, which is shown in the after credits scene of At World's End, occurred in August 1739, which means Will was killed by Davy Jones during the Battle of Calypso's maelstrom in August 1729. The official At World's End novelization sets the events of At World's End a few months after the events of Dead Man's Chest which sets the Destruction of the Edinburgh Trader in 1729.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.